Hi Blake,
By default all users have records set to be "shared". If you prefer to have each user see their own assigned records, go to the "Customize" tab > Users > select a user on the list > "Edit" > go to steps 7 of 10 and instead of "Shares all Records", uncheck that option and define if you'd like this user to share any records with an(other).
Try it out!
If you would like to use our live chat option, go to www.method.me and you will find a green bubble at the bottom right hand corner. :)