Hey Stephanie,
When creating a reoccurring activity, you will need to do that from Method rather than Outlook.
Also in the settings:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/83de4/83de47ca5023998a421ce59b494770d22a0fa123" alt=""
If you do create a reoccurring activity in Method, note this option if you want to have a larger date range sync over.
-- Mortaza